Sheridan, IN

Sheridan's
Deli
does it right.

From the first slice of fresh bread to the last bite — every sandwich, every sub, every plate is made with the kind of care that turns a lunch break into something worth coming back for.

See the Menu (317) 758-4887
Scroll
🥪 Fresh Sandwiches 🍲 Hot Entrees 🥗 House-Made Salads 🍲 Homemade Soups 📍 305 S Main St, Sheridan 📞 (317) 758-4887 🥪 Fresh Sandwiches 🍲 Hot Entrees 🥗 House-Made Salads 🍲 Homemade Soups 📍 305 S Main St, Sheridan 📞 (317) 758-4887
Interior of Tomarsha's Deli in Sheridan
Our Story

A Sheridan staple,
done with heart.

Tomarsha's Deli isn't trying to be anything it's not. We're a no-fuss, no-frills deli on Main Street in Sheridan — the kind of place where you know your order before you sit down, and the food shows up exactly how you like it.

That doesn't mean we take the easy way out. Every sandwich is built fresh, every soup is simmered properly, and every plate that leaves our kitchen is something we'd be proud to eat ourselves. Simple standards, done right.

Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch on your break or settling in for a proper meal, we've got a seat for you and a menu that doesn't need a glossary.

Fresh Ingredients Made Daily Local & Loved
"The kind of place where the food tastes better because they actually care about making it right."

— That's what our regulars say

Visit Us

Find Us

Right on Main Street — hard to miss, easy to remember.

Address

305 S Main St
Sheridan, IN 46069

Hours

Monday – Friday Call for hours
Saturday Call for hours
Sunday Call for hours

Hours may vary — we recommend calling ahead.

Get in Touch

Hungry? Call us.

Whether it's a quick lunch, a catered event, or just a question about our daily specials — we're here. Give us a ring or drop us an email.

(317) 758-4887 Email Us
Is this your business?This is my business